There has been
a lot of conversation on my Twitter lately about "the smear test", or cervical screening, and not all of it has been positive. A lot of my Twitter friends are just having their first tests now, and are unsure of what to expect, or a little bit scared that it will be a painful experience, which it honestly can be for some women. There has also been talk about sexual and obstetric abuse and trauma, and how that contributes to fear around cervical screening, which can be triggering for some people, and also about the experience of non-binary, trans and queer people who have a cervix and need the screening done. Please note that I have very little experience working with this population, and have used the term women throughout this post, not as an intentional erasure of this population, but because I have not yet experienced working with anyone who identifies as other than a woman in this context. However, I pride myself on individualisation of care, and if I have a client who identifies as other than a woman, or uses different pronouns, I am obviously going to respect this and treat that person in a sensitive and appropriate manner. So, because women's health is a huge passion of mine, and as I am both a midwife who does these tests on women, and a woman who undergoes the procedure myself, I thought I would put together a little informative post aimed at both women and health care professionals about what to expect in the procedure and also how it can be made a more comfortable and less triggering experience for all women.
First of all, I'd like to remind my international readers that I am Australian, and therefore we have slightly different terminology and protocols for cervical screening. The Australian cervical screening protocol has just recently changed, and it looks as though our protocol has moved to be more in line with the UK protocol. The procedure itself is the same, so this post will be helpful to you regardless of what country you are in, but timeframes for when to be tested are slightly different. If you're from the UK,
you can find that information here, and if you're Australian, the information below will be accurate for you.
Why get cervical screening done?
The new cervical screening test is looking for the presence of Human Pappilomavirus (HPV), which is the virus responsible for most forms of cervical cancer, whereas the old pap smear test was looking for changes to the cervical cells that could indicate that they are pre-cancerous.
Two strains of HPV, HPV-16 and HPV-18, are responsible for over 70% of cervical cancers. It is very rare for cervical cancer to have a cause other than HPV, and neither the old pap smear test or the new cervical screening test detected the early changes responsible in those cases. These types of cancers are usually found when women report symptoms like pain or abnormal bleeding, and should be investigated regardless of how long it has been since your last cervical screening test.
Getting the cervical screening test done is the best way to prevent and detect cervical cancer caused by HPV. If HPV is detected in the cervical screening test, the sample can then be further examined for changes to the cervical cells.
It is also a great opportunity to talk to your health care provider about your sexual health. The health care provider will examine you externally and internally for any abnormalities, including signs of sexually transmitted infections, or moles that may need to be investigated for melanoma, and you may be offered STI testing at the same time, or use the opportunity to talk about contraceptive options.
How is the cervical screening test done?
Cervical screening is done every 5 years in Australia, from the age of 25. The regime is slightly different in the UK. Cervical screening is more effective than the pap smear, which is why the interval of time between tests has increased with the introduction of the new test.
The cervical screening test is done by collecting a small sample of cells from the cervix with a cytobrush, which is pictured below. A speculum (which I am holding in the header picture) is used to hold open the vaginal walls so that the health care provider can see the cervix, and then the cytobrush is inserted just inside the cervical opening, rotated quickly to collect the cells, then removed. The cyto-brush is then dipped into a substance called thin-prep which preserves the sample for it to be tested at a pathology laboratory. Insertion of the speculum is uncomfortable, and collection of the sample is a little bit painful for most women, but it is over quickly,

Traditionally, for the test to be done, women are asked to lay on a gynaecology exam table, with their pants off, their bottom right on the edge of the table and their feet on or legs in stirrups. This position is known as lithotomy, and is an incredibly vulnerable and uncomfortable position to hold, which women often need assistance to get out of, especially if their legs are in full stirrups. The health care provider will then insert the speculum, which is lubricated, into the vagina, open the speculum and collect the sample before removing the speculum and providing a tissue to the woman to wipe off any excess lubricant before getting dressed again.
So, what can be done to make cervical screening more comfortable for women?
First of all, no one should undergo a test or procedure without giving full informed consent to it. This should include a pre-appointment discussion of the information outlined above, showing the woman the equipment used in the procedure and explaining how and why it is used and giving the woman the opportunity to ask questions about the procedure. Knowledge is power, and familiarising the woman with the equipment used helps to break down the fear associated with getting the test done. Information and consent should be given with the woman seated fully clothed at eye level with the practitioner (I know this sounds totally common sense but you'd be surprised how many doctors and midwives try to explain things to women when they already have their pants off and are lying down in a vulnerable position. This is not ok.)
For almost all women, it is possible to get rid of lithotomy and the gynaecology table when doing a cervical screening test. For some women with a retroverted uterus or who have a high BMI, it may be necessary to use the gynaecology table and lithotomy position to view the cervix properly, but it should be tried on a regular bed first.
To examine a woman without them being in lithotomy position, they should be positioned on a flat and firm bed or couch and allowed to relax until the procedure is about to begin, with a blanket over their lap once they have removed their pants for privacy. When the practitioner is ready to start the examination, they should ask the woman to position herself with her feet together up close to her bottom, and let her knees splay out to the sides, relaxing her bottom. The woman should lift the blanket herself when she is ready for the examination to begin. A common reason that health care providers give for the necessity of the gynaecology table in doing the cervical screening test is that the speculum handle needs room to point downward, however it is perfectly fine to use the speculum upside down, with the handle pointing up, allowing for the woman's bottom to be comfortably positioned on a bed. If you are not offered this option, you can definitely request it. Being positioned comfortably helps you to relax during the procedure, decreasing pain and fear.
The woman should be offered to self-insert the speculum. If you are not offered to self-insert the speculum, you can ask to do so. The handle does not need to be sterile, and therefore it is perfectly ok to touch the handle, but hand washing should be encouraged first. The speculum should be turned sideways as it is first inserted into the vagina, then rotated as it advances along the vaginal canal. If the woman declines to self-insert the speculum, the health care provider should ask if it is ok to touch the woman now before parting the labia and gently and slowly inserting the speculum, talking the woman through the process of inserting, opening and any adjusting necessary to visualise the cervix.
The health care provider should check in with the woman throughout the procedure, making sure she is ok, and explaining each step of the process as it is done, and any visual findings so that the woman is an active participant in her health care.
If a woman has a retroverted uterus, you can ask them to sit on their fists to tilt their uterus, but a more comfortable option would be to get them to sit on a rolled blanket or towel, which will provide the same tilt but be more comfortable. This should be tried before lithotomy position.
If a woman has a large BMI, or vaginal prolapse, using the finger of a large sterile glove with the ends cut off to stretch over the bills of the speculum to create a barrier for the vaginal wall should help to be able to visualise the cervix without resorting to lithotomy.
Sensitive language should always be used including correct pronouns, and avoiding the use of phrases such as "good girl" which may be triggering for victims of sexual assault. A chaperone should be offered to all women as well to maintain their safety.
If a woman is finding the procedure particularly uncomfortable or painful, the reason why, including physical and psychological reasons, should be explored and treated and pain relief should be offered, Some women with anxiety may benefit from taking anti-anxiety medication before the procedure, and anyone who has previously found an examination to be painful should be offered nitrous oxide gas or at the very least, panadol before their appointment to make it more comfortable. If it is your first time having the smear done and you are finding it especially painful, let your care provider know and ask if there is anything you can do to make it more comfortable, or any pain relief you can take. You may wish to stop the examination, re-book your appointment and take pain relief prior to attendance, and this wish should be honoured by your care provider, who should cease the examination immediately upon your withdrawal of consent.
The option for self testing has recently come in in Australia for women over 30 who are overdue for their test or who have never been tested before. Self testing takes samples from the vagina rather than the cervix, and therefore cannot detect precancerous or cancerous cervical cells, but will detect the presence of HPV in the vagina. Therefore, it is less effective than the test done by a health care provider. I think this is a great idea for women with serious trauma who cannot sit through the cervical screening test to make it more accessible, but I honestly believe that if all health care providers adhered to the simple steps above to make the test more comfortable for women, a lot less women would find them traumatic and feel the need to do the self-test.
So that's it! A few simple steps that can make cervical screening more comfortable for women!
Change rarely comes from health care providers, who have been trained in a certain way in which they are comfortable. It comes from the consumer. It's important to find a trusted health care provider to do your cervical screening tests, and be your own advocate in asking for these simple measures to make it a more comfortable experience for yourself. If every woman asked for these things, it would soon become the norm!
I hope this post has been helpful to you, whether you're a woman readying yourself for your first cervical screening test, or a health care provider looking for ways to make the test more comfortable for your clients. More information on screening in Australia can be
found here, and on self testing can be
found here. UK specific information can be
found here. If you have any questions, please reach out to me on social media, email me at sunae.reilly@gmail.com or leave a comment here on the blog. I'd love to hear from you!
Pin this image!